Baby Walkers- Why you’ll never see a physical therapist recommend one

By baby walkers, I don’t mean babies that walk, I mean those moving chairs that babies are placed in.

I wanted to bring up this topic because I recently saw a patient that was nearly 2 years old but not walking yet.  The patient’s parent told me that the patient cruised a little around their home, but mostly walked in a walker like the one pictured above.

I told the parent to just toss that walker right in the trash or to give it away (though I wouldn’t want anyone else using a walker!).  The day after removing the walker from their home, the patient began taking their first steps.  The parent thought I did something great, but mostly it was removing the walker from the home along with some tips and tricks that I will bring up in a later post (stay tuned to next week’s Tips and Tricks Tuesdays!)

Here are the reasons why PTs say No way to baby walkers:

  1. Walkers are simply NOT SAFE!- From a study in 2006 that investigated Walker-related injuries, “An estimated 197200 infant walker-related injuries occurred among children who were younger than 15 months and treated in US emergency departments from 1990 through 2001.”  Canada has banned walker use since 2004 and can fine someone up to $100,000 or 6 months in jail. “Trauma to the head region occurred in 91% of cases. Skull fractures were the most common (62%) type of fracture. Falls down stairs was the mechanism of injury in 74% of cases.” (link to study here)
  2. Walker use delays motor development #1.  When you’re sitting in a chair surrounded by a giant bumper and then allowed to walk anywhere you want and crash into anything, it really doesn’t force your brain/body to practice balancing on its own.
  3. Walker use delays motor development #2. This relates to #1.  Being in a walker doesn’t allow a child to see where their feet are when they walk.  Being able to see our hands/feet as they move is important for brain development, and specifically proprioception. Proprioception is basically our brain’s ability to know where our limbs are in space without looking at them.  So if a child doesn’t have the opportunity to learn this, it can affect their balance later.
  4. Walker use delays other milestones.  Children are typically placed in walkers soon after they can stand, which is usually before they can crawl.  Placing them in a walker can delay crawling because being in a walker doesn’t allow further development of hand-eye coordination for crawling.  You can read my previous post about the benefits of crawling.
  5. Walker use can lead to mental delays. In the October, 1999 Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics [1999;20:355-361]- “On a standard test of mental development, no-walker babies had the highest average score, followed by babies who used “see-feet” walkers and those who used newer walkers.”
  6. Walker use can lead to greater delays in a child who is already developmentally delayed. “The authors note, other investigators have found that in developmentally-challenged babies, babies born prematurely and very young infants, walkers may be particularly likely to cause problems with balance and alignment.”

Alternative to walkers:

Push Toys- 

 

 

 

Exersaucers (though don’t leave your children in here for an extended period of time either!)- Need to make sure your child can stand well in these so they do not try to stand on their toes or stiffen their legs to stay balanced.

 

 

 

Or just try simply walking holding hands! (but remember to keep hands at your child’s shoulder height.

Resources I used for this post:

http://www.babyzone.com/products/baby-gear/baby-walkers_69266

http://aapgrandrounds.aappublications.org/content/3/1/1.extract

http://consults.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/22/the-dangers-of-baby-walkers/

http://www.brainy-child.com/article/babywalker.shtml

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16510623

 



Categories: Child Development

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

8 replies

  1. First of all, never say never! I don’t like baby walkers either , but As a pedi PT I have learned to live with them in SOME situations, and even will try a toddler aged child who is not yet walking in one. OMG! A PT recommending them. YES,with conditions! I believe that in order to teach a child to walk, a child needs to experience walking. And in order to learn a child needs to explore his environment (Ahh remember Piaget!) Sometimes a child needs to know that he can move without adult assistance. So if a parent has a walker, and they are using it with their child who is motorically delayed, then I work with the family. Look to see how the child looks in it. What kind of support is he getting. Sometimes I put the child in backwards so that he gets better trunk support. Sometimes I pad the ring so that there is better alignment. And sometimes I even take out the seat and (with supervision) allow the child to “walk” in it without being able to sit. Of course everything in moderation and I would urge that a parent use it for short periods of time during their day.
    In a therapeutic environment I would likely not use a baby walker: I would use a treadmill &/or BWB and some facilitation and resistance. But in the home, where those resources probably are not be available, I work with what the family has and what the child is capable of doing. And warn the family of the dangers of unsupervised play in any piece of equipment. So, I never say never!

    Like

  2. You are Right but proper design of baby walker
    is also very helpful to baby. baby walker

    Like

  3. Thanks for sharing so much details about baby walker especially on the alternatives.

    Like

Trackbacks

  1. Tips and Tricks Tuesdays!- Progressing to Walking Part 1 | Beyond Basic Play
  2. Are baby walkers safe?
  3. Tips and Tricks Tuesdays- Progressing to Walking Part 2 | Beyond Basic Play
  4. Montessori at Home | Rusty, Roaming, & Ruthless
  5. Tips and Tricks Tuesdays!- Progressing to Walking Part 1 - Beyond Basic Play

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: